I've think that the film was great. I myself have a hobby like that you do... and i am a huge bad religion fan.. and the song was, how can i say "exelente"

This was a truly great song... hope they'll put out a b-side album some time.

Comments by fantasticthepan from United States on 2006-06-20 @ 18:29
two things:
1) i think this is a great video. very impressive. makes you wonder why br continually blows opportunities to make their emotionally potent songs into average visual works. 2)..."its typical brett to exclude it solely for the production value."...
1.) usually because we are in it.
2.) brett wrote that song and excluded it because it wasn't finished...

Very nice video man. The song was great too, never heard it before.

two things:
1) i think this is a great video. very impressive. makes you wonder why br continually blows opportunities to make their emotionally potent songs into average visual works. 2) i understand that this was a pob outtake. it definitely has that pob sound of the songs towards the end of the album starting w/ the lie, bored and extremely dangerous. my point is, i think this song is waaaaaay better than "...missy was a teen blue video star" or whatever. it's very similar to that song, but has much better lyrics and greg's voice definitely hits a deeper emotional tone. its cool to have as an outtake but its typical brett to exclude it solely for the production value. i like the production of this. its the first time i've heard it and it would've been an asset to pob, but in place of "the lie" probably.

I'm impressed by the video, it's a really good job. Thank you!!!

Here's a link to the .mpg file that I ripped off Youtube:
http://tinyurl.com/rt9t3
If anyone gets a link to a better quality one, post it here, ok?
Thanks.

So, any link to a video download?
I'm gonna rip it off Youtube, but I'm hoping that there's gonna be a better quality one somewhere.

I believe it was on Punk-O-Rama 8.
Check www.bad-religion.net for all your mp3 needs.

How come I've never heard this song! It's not even up in the lyrics page of this website; does anyone know where I can get it from??

I went to the journalism film festival tonight at my college (U of O) and this video was shown and I thought it was so awesome! Coming from another amateur filmmaker, I was very impressed. It didn't win Best Music Video award though, there was a funny, rediculous rap video that won. Then for me to come onto the BR Page and this is posted as news, it's tripping me out! Rock on!

Jay did not state that Shattered Faith was recorded only by Greg. It was a group effort, but Jay was reluctant in doing so.

Yeah, now that I think of it, I somehow confused it with Out of Hand. But I remember hearing something particular about Shattered Faith in relation to how they recorded or mixed it. I'll try to check in my BR Archives and get back to you all.

shattered faith wasnt recorded by just greg... you should be able to tell by listening to it

So Shattered Faith was recorded just by Greg?

I do like Shattered Faith, but it gets old quickly, and it does sound a bit too much like Kid's Arn't Alright.
However, you can't deny that the bit where Greg goes "Now there's doubt...
...And gravity..."
And then it kicks right back in again is amazing!

To whoever made the video:
Excellent job. I'm impressed.

Yeah, you're talking about The Offspring's The Kids (Aren't Alright). You're right, I think it was Jay who admitted that on the recent BR Podcast and added that Graffin had recorded that song on his own.

Shattered Faith sounds too much like an Offspring song(I forget which one). And Jay has stated he didn't even want to record that song, let alone be apart of it.
News From The Front on the other hand, is awesome! And Who we are is Awesome too... but there are reasons why b-sides and "unreleased" songs exist... also there are reasons why certain songs don't make albums...it's all relative if you ask me... just as long as I get t hear them.

Shattered Faith is indeed one hell of a song but still Who We Are > Shattered Faith... After all, Brett > Greg.

Bedouin, ONLY on the European and Japanese versions...

I've never heard of this song.

News from the front IS on my Stranger than Fiction record...but I can't believe Shattered Faith didn't make the cut to whichever album it was written for. That's a great song.

great fucking work, man!

I gotta say, hell of a job on the video. Great production work, I see no reason why bad religion wouldn't want to use this video as their own. Once again, great work and i'm sure you'll succeed in your film career. This is a nice addition to your portfolio as well, with nothing but great reviews haha.

n00b...

Part III from Netherlands said on 2006-06-14 @ 20:19
but Brett didnt like the way it was produced so it didnt make the record
Wrongly so! Another Bad Religion sin, the first one being News from the Front not making it to STF either.

The Video is cool !
And it's my favorite Song of Bad Religion ! :D

Who We Are is off a Punk O Rama compilation, it was originally written as a song for TPOB, but Brett didnt like the way it was produced so it didnt make the record

Who We Are was a bonus track on Process of Belief.
Wow, I never noticed the reference to The New America!
Cool!

Cool video for school, but where did "Who we are" come from, I could'nt locate the song anywhere.

Yeah, anyway you can still see Greg's mouth there lol
However, I don't think it's a rule that bands have to be in their videos for them to qualify as good videos.

I like it a lot! Props to this guy! At the beginning, it kinda reminded me of Struck a Nerve in the sense that it follows some of the images described in the verses line by line (a cigarette, a memory). It shows the guy is a fan of Bad Religion. I liked the references to The Gray Race (one of the faces of the album cover mixed in one of those subliminal "curtains" borrowed from the LA Is Burning vieo) and (the European version of) The New America (the way he is standing with the gun pressed to his chest).

Bad Religion isn't in it because some guy made it in school. I think it's fucking great, better than most of Bad Religions real videos. Good job!!

It would have been cooler if bad religion was in it. But it's very nice! I like it better than 10 in 2010